Not All Supplements Are Created Equal — Part 1


What You Need to Know Before Choosing A Supplement Regimen

Keith I. Block, MD

As you’re probably aware, Dr. Mehmet Oz appeared in front of Congress last week where he was extensively questioned about his endorsement of some weight loss products that were featured on his daytime talk show. Because the efficacy of these specific supplements remains unproven – and Dr. Oz himself admitted they lacked the “scientific muster to present as fact” – the focus of the controversy and ensuing media discussions were on the appropriateness of his endorsement. However, with supplements back in the news, this is a good time to remind our readers of the importance of being an educated consumer.

Most people are surprised to learn that neither the FDA nor any other regulatory agency ensures the potency or purity of dietary supplements. In fact, manufacturers don’t even have to provide the FDA with safety data prior to making them available for sale! It isn’t until a product is on the market that the FDA is charged with tracking the side effects reported by consumers, healthcare professionals and the supplement manufacturers themselves. So, let’s take a closer look at these two fundamental issues of supplement quality: purity and potency.

Purity-related concerns are primarily about contamination and adulteration. A supplement can be contaminated by bacteria, heavy metals and/or drug residues; all three factors can be introduced at various points of the processing of supplements. Health-related concerns are different for each type of contamination: bacteria might lead to infection, heavy metals to toxicity, and drug residues to untoward physiological effects.

Most of the reported problems concerning adulteration and contamination are around herbal products. For example, herbal producers in China are known to treat their raw materials with sulfur dioxide, which is presently not allowed here in the U.S. Among the major contributors to heavy metal contamination are mercury fungicides, lead and arsenic insecticides, and industrial and automobile emissions. Even many wild-crafted herbs (those harvested in the wild) frequently show a high concentration of heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and cadmium.

Some herbal formulas from Asia contain toxic heavy metal salts, as these can play a role in some traditional medicine systems. In addition, herbal producers in Asia will often add prescription and non-prescription drugs to their herbal preparations. Among the residues found in these herbs are acetaminophen, diazepam, hydrocortisone, indomethacin, methyltestosterone, phenylbutazone, and prednisone. As shocking as this sounds, in some countries, combinations of what we consider prescription drugs with herbal medicine are in line with local regulations and therefore, including them in herbal supplements is common practice. However, in the United States, supplements and drugs are clearly separated because of the potential harm in giving someone a prescription drug without their knowledge. Obviously, you should be very cautious about using any imported formulas without knowing exactly what is in them and discussing their use with your integrative practitioner or physician.

Another concern is that not all supplements provide what they claim to provide, and some may be so contaminated that they may put your long-range health in jeopardy. Some of the contamination is a byproduct of the way these herbs are handled before they ever hit the marketplace. For example, many of the machines, utensils and brewing containers that are used in processing the herbs may contribute to heavy metal contamination. If the herbs have not undergone proper drying and storage, the crude plant material can become infested with microorganisms that are capable of producing mycotoxins. Several of these mycotoxins can in turn generate aflatoxins, which have actually been linked to various cancers.

Given these facts, quality issues must not be overlooked when selecting supplements.  One of the ways supplement manufacturers can verify the potency, purity, and bioavailability of their supplement is to have the raw materials independently tested for both purity and potency. Of course, it’s important to be sure that the laboratory used for the testing has no ongoing fiscal relationship with the supplement manufacturer or with the supplier of raw materials. This kind of independent verification helps to prevent fraudulent misrepresentation by companies that simply want to promote their product.

Fundamental to ensuring a supplement is high-quality, is ensuring the ingredients used are high quality – that is, herbs that are grown under controlled conditions using seeds of a known species and variety of plant; harvested when their phytochemical contents are most advantageous; processed quickly, cleanly and efficiently; and maintained under clean conditions while they are being shipped and incorporated in the process of manufacturing a supplement. Some companies specialize in obtaining and preparing herbs in this way, and then preparing extracts that simply concentrate the entire plant. In many cases, whole plant extracts are the best products to use. They include the full spectrum of phytochemicals in the plant. If an herbal extract is made using water (or some other solvents), for instance, only the water-soluble components of the plant will be in the extract. However, many herbs contain important non-water soluble components, and these would be missing. You could, of course, simply take the entire unprocessed herb, but in many instances, you would need to take a large number of capsules to get as much herb as you need. A process called “supercritical extraction” – similar to the process used for decaffeinated coffee but without the use of potentially problematic solvents – yields a whole plant extract that is highly concentrated. Some excellent supplements are made through the combination of careful sourcing of the fresh herbal material and supercritical extraction. In general, I advocate the use of whole plants in both herbs and foods, since these are the closest to the natural forms of plants that humans have been eating for millennia. However, in some cases, I also will use whole plant extracts that have specific compounds of known biological activity added to them.

Standardized extracts are another way that manufacturers approach the problem of quality control. Standardized extracts contain specified amounts of certain named phytochemicals based on what is scientifically thought to be the optimal concentration of the most effective array of phytochemicals. When a supplement is standardized, you can feel more confident that you’re getting what the label says. Standardization is achieved by several means: by making an extract containing only the phytochemicals that are thought to be effective (active) for a particular condition, by blending herbal extracts; by spiking with the active constituent or by standardizing to what is referred to as a “marker” compound. The marker compound is a phytochemical that is unique to the species of plant that is present in the extract.

By using standardized products, you know with some assurance how much of the active ingredient is actually present in the supplement. And for some ingredients, it is optimal to use products that are high in specific phytochemicals.  Let me give you an example of how this plays out in my clinical practice. My research team and I have formulated a decaffeinated green tea extract with a very high concentration – standardized to 70 percent of epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG). One gram of the EGCG supplement is equivalent to 35 grams of green tea. Since the typical bag of green tea contains 1.6 grams of tea, a daily dose of our supplement (8 tablets) contains the equivalent of more than fifty cups of green tea! Additionally, in taking this supplement, my patients are able to bypass the stimulating effect of caffeine, typically found in green tea.

In our next blog post, we’ll examine the issue of potency, which refers to both the strength and freshness of the supplement, as well as the quantity or concentration of active ingredients.

One response to “Not All Supplements Are Created Equal — Part 1

  1. Thank you, Dr. Block, for your integrity and dedication to providing the finest care available to anyone with health issues and/or concerns. You enable us to feel the best we can, physically, while giving us the sense of assurance, encouragement, and emotional support that is required to move forward in our recovery. I was certain when I read about you and the research you were conducting and involved with decades ago, that you were someone I “needed to know.” I’m so glad I found you and the Block Medical Center. As a patient/participant, I can testify that your integrative and individualized healthcare programs and supplement protocols are the finest available anywhere. Again, thank you and Penny, and your wonderful staff of professionals who deliver “Care as unique as you are.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *